TOBY HARNDEN: Rick Perry’s bizarre mind-change on South Carolina could hand GOP nomination to Mitt Romney

By
Toby Harnden

Last updated at 11:59 PM on 5th January 2012

Governor Rick Perry’s presidential campaign has been utterly baffling. The contrast between his superbly-managed entry into the race last August, eclipsing the Ames Straw Poll and stopping Michele Bachmann in her tracks, and the aftermath of the Iowa caucuses could not have be starker.

After finishing a disastrous fifth (as a social conservative and former Texas Agriculture Commissioner, Iowa should have been his to win) he announced on Tuesday night that he was returning to the governor’s mansion in Austin for ‘a little prayer and reflection’ and to ‘reassess’ his campaign.

That seemed to be clear shorthand for signalling that he was dropping out of the race, particularly as it involved cancelling events in South Carolina yesterday.

Strange decision: By staying in the Republican presidential race, Rick Perry could hand victory to Mitt Romney

Strange decision: By staying in the Republican presidential race, Rick Perry could hand victory to Mitt Romney

But then Perry surprised everyone, including some of his own staff, by deciding that he would, after all, compete in the South Carolina primary on January 21st. All this follows a Politico story containing some epic mud-slinging between different factions within the Perry campaign.

Perry said that he went out jogging and was ‘out on the trail when it kind of came to me’ that he should continue his bid for the White House. Perry’s runs can be eventful – he famously shot a coyote with a .380 Ruger pistol.

The decision to stay in makes little sense. After a fifth in Iowa and skipping New Hampshire next Tuesday Perry’s chances of the presidency are somewhere between very slim and zero. And his Hamlet-like indecision after Iowa won’t help with donors or supporters.

Of course, the person who stands to gain most from Perry staying in is Mitt Romney. Even if Perry – who is a South Carolina kind of candidate – polls only a few percentage points there then that could be enough to split the vote and give the former Massachusetts victory or second place.

Celebration: Romney is well-placed to become the GOP's candidate after his narrow win in the Iowa caucuses on Tuesday night

Celebration: Romney is well-placed to become the GOP’s candidate after his narrow win in the Iowa caucuses on Tuesday night

Perry’s exit might have meant more much-needed dollars flowing to Rick Santorum – and, who knows, perhaps even some big bucks from Perry’s ‘Super PAC’ Make Us Great Again.

Remember, it was Fred Thompson’s 15 per cent in South Carolina that stopped Mike Huckabee winning there, thereby handing the nomination to John McCain. I recall Thompson’s staff telling me how Huckabee had begged Thompson to withdraw from the race (like Perry, he clearly wasn’t going to win) but Fred was not for turning.

In the days after his Charleston announcement, Perry rocketed to frontrunner status and, as the 10-year governor of a job-creating state, appeared to be on course for the nomination if he kept his nerve, campaigned with some discipline and performed averagely well in the debates. Of course, his ‘Oops’ moment in Michigan ended all that, though he was already on the slide by then.

Exactly why Perry changed his mind about pulling out – he surely believed he would when he spoke on Tuesday – is a matter of much speculation. It could have been Texas pride. Some might wonder whether the Romney campaign made overtures, though relations between the two men have never been warm.

Whatever the reason for the decision, Perry’s immediate legacy in this 2012 race (and the odds have got to be on him being out by the time Florida votes on January 31st or shortly afterwards) may be to deny Santorum the juice he needed and deliver the nomination to Mitt Romney.

Here’s what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts,
or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have not been moderated.

Toby, methinks your grasp of American politics leaves something to be desired.
Fact is that Perry was always Romney’s #1 fear for a good reason, he’s got the total package that can unite conservatives and conservative donors, a coalition of votersand money guys that constitutes about 200% of Romney’s base. In Iowa, these folks were fractured. In S. Carolina, Perry stands to have a regional advantage as a southerner. I don’t know anyone who is sophisticated about politics who didn’t understand that Perry’s time out statement was simply a ploy to get a good ‘new start’ headline and to clear the air before heading to S. Carolina. If he fails in S. Carolina he’s toast, but it would be dumb for him to back out before the Carolinians have spoken.

I’ve been thinking back on Perry’s actions over the past couple months. His actions are erratic to the point where I begin to wonder if he is having a problem with substance abuse. I remember him commenting about his lack of concentration after one of the debates was due to medication for a back injury. I think his handlers should get someone in to evaluate his situation. Of course, I don’t know anything for sure…. but I’ve had a lot of experience with people with substance abuse.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Views: 0

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: Premium WordPress Themes | Thanks to Themes Gallery, Bromoney and Wordpress Themes