Thousands of patients may have been misdiagnosed at a hospital in Bristol

By
Daily Mail Reporter

Last updated at 12:46 PM on 19th February 2012

Fears: Catherine Calland is planning to sue Bristol Royal Infirmary where as many as 7,000 errors could have been made

Fears: Catherine Calland is planning to sue Bristol Royal Infirmary where as many as 7,000 errors could have been made

Thousands of patients suffering with cancer may have been misdiagnosed at a hospital in Bristol, according to whistleblowers.

An investigation at the Bristol Royal Infirmary (BRI) has revealed nearly 7,000 serious errors could have been made over the past 10 years.

Cases include a retired nurse with terminal cancer who says she was dismissed by doctors as ‘hysterical’ for wanting a breast lump removed.

Catherine Calland, 65, was wrongly given the all-clear after a series of tests nearly seven years ago.

Although she told medics she had a ‘bad feeling’ about the lump on her left breast, she claims she was laughed at.

Just one year later, Mrs Calland was diagnosed with fatal malignant lymphoma.

Other cases include a former NHS manager of cancer services who died after her breast cancer went undetected.

Jane Hopes died from breast cancer in 2004 after a lump was  wrongly classed as benign.

Her husband, Reg Hill and Mrs Calland, are now preparing to sue the hospital.

Pathologists were alleged to have misread the results on at least 26 people between 2004 and 2008.

When independent pathologists reexamined those 26 cases, they found only seven had actually been correct.

Tests: Catherine Calland had her initial mammogram at Bristol's University Hospital's Central Health Clinic in December 2005 which showed the lump was benign (pictured posed by models)

Tests: Catherine Calland had her initial mammogram at Bristol’s University Hospital’s Central Health Clinic in December 2005 which showed the lump was benign (pictured posed by models)

A report, commissioned by United Hospitals Bristol Trust (UHBT), admits that out of a further 3,500 cases, 3.4 per cent may have been misdiagnosed. 

The hospital examines more than 20,000 specimens a year which could mean as many as 6,800 errors over the past decade. 

Dr Nasif Ibrahim, a consultant pathologist at North Bristol trust who retired last year, told The Sunday Telegraph: ‘A three per cent error rate would never be acceptable.

‘I would not have wanted a biopsy from a member of my family to go there.’

A group of campaigners, led by former breast cancer patient Daphne Havercroft, are now calling for the hospital not to merge the BRI pathology unit with other services because they believe more patients will be put at risk. 

UHBT has apologised to patients and said it is focused on improving the unit.  

A spokesman said the inquiry’s independent panel found no evidence to suggest the department was not safe.

Here’s what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts,
or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

Fist the babies, now this and the ongoing failing at the cancer treatment center – its utterly failing as a hospital despite all the dozens of managers on six figure salaries that run it.

And I got my letter from them to review my cervical smear – no thanks !

It is disgraceful, unfortunately I see these mistakes increasing though. They are closing down and merging pathology labs all over the country and making highly skilled staff redundant to save money! The NHS is on the way down, yet again the government is failing us!

My heart goes out to this lady, we have an innate instinct which should be taken very seriously, as with mothers` and babies. So often dismissed or ridiculed, we function differently to men. My thoughts and prayers are with her.

And over 50% of cancers are due to lifestyle. So, we’re blaming an overstretched NHS due to obesity and drunken saturday nights, for NOT picking up the pieces that over 50% of the population leave behind from their own lifestyle choices.

and over 50% of cancers are due to lifestyle. So stop doing it.

i sincerely hope my local GP practice do not use BRI pathology service. I will ensure any investigations i have do not go there. Why do these types of organisations regularly fail us?

All the money that we the tax payer pay for the NHS and all we ask for in return is that they treat us with respect and dignity.. Oh and they get the diagnoses right!

What an absolute and utter disgrace!!

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Views: 0

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: Premium WordPress Themes | Thanks to Themes Gallery, Bromoney and Wordpress Themes