How Ivanhoe has been cut down to size: Classic novel rewritten because 179,000 word original is too long

By
Daily Mail Reporter

Last updated at 2:24 AM on 30th January 2012


A tough read: Cover of the classic book Ivanhoe by Sir Walter Scott

A tough read: Cover of the classic book Ivanhoe by Sir Walter Scott which has been cut from 179,000 words to 80,000

A classic Scots novel has been rewritten – because modern readers find the original too long.

Ivanhoe by Sir Walter Scott tells the story of a 12th century knight, Wilfred of Ivanhoe. But at 179,000 the tale is too wordy to appeal to many modern booklovers.

In an attempt to appeal to a new readership, the president of the Sir Walter Scott Club, Professor David Purdie, has spent 18 months cutting the epic down to just 80,000 words.

While Prof Purdie has retained the antiquated writing style used by Scott, he has taken out the swathes of punctuation which extend the novel.

He said: ‘Very few people read Scott these days because he’s long and wordy and difficult for the modern ear and modern attention span.
‘I had this idea that I would have a goat redacting, abridging and adapting.’

Prof Purdie says that if his new version is successful he could give other Scott books the same treatment.

He said: ‘Scott dominates Princes Street in a monument but not in its bookshops.

‘I would just like to see Scott back in the shops in a format that might entrance the young reader.’

Prof
Purdie said his version of the text had been ‘repunctuated’ and taken
out many commas and semicolons to make shorter, more modern sentences.

‘In the early 19th century, a comma was places after every phrase, which makes it tedious reading,’ he said.

However the move has not met with approval with all the members of the 119-year-old Scott Club.

FILM: IVANHOE (1952) Pictured: Robert Taylor and Elizabeth Taylor

Star attraction: Robert Taylor and Elizabeth Taylor starred in the 1952 film based on the book

Television programme IVANHOE Roger Moore as Ivanhoe is forced backwards by the treacherous Sir Maurice played by Anthony Dawson Roger Moore starred from 1958 -1959

From book to screen: Roger Moore, left, playing Ivanhoe is forced backwards by the treacherous Sir Maurice played by Anthony Dawson in the 1958 to 1959 TV show

Purdie said: ‘Some of the older
members say you are toying with the original text. The younger members
say its good, if its much more readable than the original I’m for it.’

The
club secretary Professor Peter Garside, who specialises in Scottish
literature, said: ‘A Scott purist would say that Scott wrote it a
certain way, and that’s how he intended it to be.

Something
which is a reduction of Scott, and introducing new elements, is
producing something which is not Scott himself, but could have a
beneficial effect in inspiring new interesr and possibly leading people
back to the original text.

Every effort to make Scott more widely available to the general readership should be applauded.’

HO CHI MINH

Ivanhoe fan: Ivanhoe is said to be one of Tony Blair's favourite books

Famous fans: Tony Blair, right, said it he would take Ivanhoe to a desert island with him, and Chinese leader Ho Chi Minh, left, praised the gallantry shown in the novel

But Professor David, a former president of the Scott Club and emeritus professor of Literature at Aberdeen University, blasted the idea that Scott books were not popular with modern Scottish readers.

The idea that Scott is neglected, no, it’s not neglected at all. ‘Ivanhoe is being well read.’ He said that Penguin editions for the book had sold around 100,000 copies in the last decade, with worldwide sales of around 200,000 copies.

However he said he would be interested to see how the new version of the book does.

‘Provided you don’t call it Sir Walter Scott, but Scott via Purdie. Or, after the novel by Sir Walter Scott,’ he said.

Ivanhoe was written in 1819 and charts the story of a Saxon noble family at a time when they were vastly outnumbered by Norman nobles.

Famous fans include Tony Blair, who said it he would take it to a desert island with him, and Chinese leader Ho Chi Minh, who praised the gallantry shown in the novel.

Screen versions of the story have starred Rodger Moore and film icon Elizabeth Taylor.

Views: 0

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: Premium WordPress Themes | Thanks to Themes Gallery, Bromoney and Wordpress Themes