It’s time to stop demonising fat – what matters is where it’s hiding, says body MRI expert
You say it’s only in recent decades that fat has been demonised. What do you mean?
For thousands of years, people who would now be considered overweight were admired. To be large was a sign of prosperity, and was associated with fertility. If you look at paintings and drawings over thousands of years, you are always going to see women with a body mass index above 25, and up to 30, who are considered beautiful. It is only in the last 30 years that we have seen a drop in BMI in such portrayals and the concept of health related to lower and lower BMIs.
Have we really got our ideas about fat so wrong?
If you stop people in the street and ask them if they are happy with their amount of fat, they will say no. If you then ask if they want to reduce it, they say yes. Ask by how much and they will say they want to reduce it completely. Getting rid of fat should not be the aim. The aim should be to have a healthy amount, but nobody thinks in those terms. We have demonised it.
Who is to blame for fat’s bad press?
There is not a day that goes by without an article in a newspaper or magazine telling you how to reduce fat. Not a single article will say, look, not only is a certain amount of fat good, but it is essential for your well-being.
How should we regard our body fat then?
Not just as a dumping ground for excess energy, which is the way most people see it, but as a beautiful organ that interacts with your environment and helps maintain homeostasis within your body. Fat controls and modulates your fertility, your appetite and your mood. Your immune response will not work properly if you don’t have the right amount of fat.
Is this demonising of fat harmful?
We have shown that people who diet strictly can have problems. Supermodels tend to have a lot of liver fat, which is unhealthy, although their BMI can be as low as 15 to 16. The separation between beauty and health has created its own problems. We now consider people to be beautiful if they have a very low BMI but it would be healthier to have a BMI of 24, with the right distribution of fat.
Is all fat good for you?
There is a reason why body fat is there and it is a reflection of your lifestyle. Too much fat, where it is and in what form might be bad. Excess fat in the liver is bad. Subcutaneous fat, particularly around your gluteal area, is protective.
So where excess fat ends up is important?
Absolutely. With new imaging techniques, we have discovered people with “sub-phenotypes” of fat distribution. They have normal levels of fat but with increased risk of certain diseases because of fat deposits in and around internal organs. This is what we call Tofi – thin on the outside, fat inside. This internal fat is believed to be more likely to lead to type 2 diabetes and heart disease. Other people can increase their external fat with very little effect on their internal fat.
If you would like to reuse any content from New Scientist, either in print or online, please contact the syndication department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to.
Have your say
Only subscribers may leave comments on this article. Please log in.
Only personal subscribers may leave comments on this article
Lipotelekinesis
Sat Jul 14 16:49:43 BST 2012 by Eric Kvaalen
Very well, but how do you tell your fat where to go?
Lipotelekinesis
Tue Jul 17 11:17:49 BST 2012 by Jamie
Exercise
Lipotelekinesis
Tue Jul 17 11:29:41 BST 2012 by Owen
There were a couple of really good documentaries on the BBC a few months ago, (which went into what this guy is talking about in a lot more detail) and the most surprising outcome from it was how little exercise you need to do to reduce your BMI and get the fat in the right places. Fat breakdown is mostly caused by the release of hormones during the first minute of exercise, and any exercise after that is surplus to requirements (if your aim is to lose fat rather than get fit), although whether it is the ‘bad fat’ or the ‘good fat’ that is broken down in this way was unclear.
The documentaries are definitely worth a watch if you can find them on BBC iPlayer
Lipotelekinesis
Thu Jul 19 08:44:22 BST 2012 by Liza
So, if I excercise one minute a day rather than an hour twice a week as I’m doing now, I should loose weight?
Lipotelekinesis
Thu Jul 19 08:40:25 BST 2012 by Liza
True, and how do you even distinguish between subcutaneous and internal belly fat? I’d like an MRI scan to find out 🙂
Fat
Wed Jul 18 09:17:00 BST 2012 by Olie
Fat was useful when we never knew where the next meal was coming and for those in colder climates to keep warm. With all our creature comforts and food stuffs in abundance we don’t really need much fat at all. Fat stores are healthy to a degree but in our society we would surely prosper with much lower levels than the average person currently has.
It is right that you can’t entirely judge a person’s health solely on their body composition. However, generally speaking, it’s a good indicator.
Fat
Sat Jul 21 09:24:54 BST 2012 by replicawatches007
http://www.replicawatches007.com
Sales rolex replica, High-quality replica rolex watches,Top brand watches,all luxury watches for sale cheap and cheapest only $59 ,Buy cheap watches online at http://www.replicawatches007.com
All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the “Report” link in that comment to report it to us.
If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.
Related posts:
Views: 0